Connect with us

Politics

Legal Experts Tear Apart Nnamdi Kanu Ruling, List 10 Major Flaws That Could Nullify the Judgment on Appeal

Legal and constitutional experts have raised alarm over Justice James Omotosho’s ruling on IPOB leader Nnamdi Kanu, describing it as riddled with jurisdictional errors, constitutional breaches.

Published

on

Court Denies Nnamdi Kanu Bail
Nnamdi Kanu in Court
  • Legal and constitutional experts have raised alarm over Justice James Omotosho’s ruling on IPOB leader Nnamdi Kanu, describing it as riddled with jurisdictional errors, constitutional breaches, and procedural irregularities—faults they say make the judgment too defective to stand on appeal.

Legal analysts and constitutional experts are raising serious concerns over the recent judgment delivered by Justice James Omotosho of the Federal High Court, Abuja, in the case involving detained IPOB leader, Mazi Nnamdi Kanu.

A detailed review of the ruling reveals multiple procedural lapses and constitutional violations that, according to experts, severely undermine the validity of the judgment.

Below is a simplified breakdown of the key issues highlighted:

1. Failure to Decide Jurisdiction Before Proceeding

Kanu’s legal team challenged the court’s jurisdiction—a mandatory legal hurdle in criminal proceedings. Instead of addressing it, Justice Omotosho proceeded with the case.
Legal experts stress that any trial conducted without resolving jurisdiction is null and void, rendering the entire process defective.

VN62

2. Directing Objections to a Final Address, Then Blocking It

The judge instructed the defence to include all objections—including jurisdictional issues—in the final written address.
However, when the time came:

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU  DETAILS: Ruling Of Kano Election Tribunal That Sacks Governor Yusuf, Declares APC Winner
  • The court blocked the filing of final addresses
  • Judgment was delivered without hearing the objections

This, analysts say, constitutes a clear breach of fair hearing.

3. No Written Rulings on Key Applications

Several defence motions were filed before judgment, including those relating to:

Advertisement
  • Illegal rendition
  • Abuse of court process
  • Double criminality
  • Repealed statutes
  • Defective charges

Justice Omotosho issued no written rulings on any of these applications. Experts note that judges are legally required to provide written decisions—failure to do so is a fatal procedural error.

4. Forcing Kanu to Plead Under a Repealed Law

Although the judge acknowledged that the Terrorism Prevention Act 2013 had been repealed, he still compelled Kanu to plead to charges framed under it.
Legal scholars maintain that a repealed law cannot sustain a criminal charge, making the proceedings invalid.

DON’T MISS: BREAKING: Nnamdi Kanu Sentenced to Life Imprisonment

5. Violating Section 36(12) of the Constitution

The Constitution states:

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU  'Scripted Judgment': Nnamdi Kanu’s Wife Blasts Justice Omotosho, Accuses Him of Violating Constitution

No one may be convicted of an offence not clearly defined in an existing written law.

Advertisement

Analysts say the judge relied on:

  • Allegations not contained in the charge
  • Claims unsupported by evidence
  • Accusations not made by any witness

One example is the claim that Kanu plotted to bomb foreign embassies during EndSARS—an allegation never mentioned by the prosecution.

VN62

6. Elevating a “Savings Clause” Above the Constitution

The court leaned on a savings clause in the new Terrorism Act that allows old cases to continue.
Experts argue:

  • A savings clause cannot override the Constitution
  • A repealed law remains repealed
  • No one may be tried under an expired law

This interpretation, they say, contradicts legal hierarchy.

7. Ignoring the Mandatory “Double Criminality” Test

Since the government alleged Kanu committed crimes in Kenya, Nigerian law requires proof that the alleged acts are also crimes in Kenya.
No such evidence—police reports, witnesses, or documentation—was presented.
Analysts say the court avoided this necessary test altogether.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU  Impeachment Suit: Obaseki Alleges That Shaibu Is Planning To Join Another Party

8. Denial of Fair Hearing Makes the Judgment Void

Blocking final addresses, ignoring objections, and failing to rule on motions all amount to denial of fair hearing.
Under Nigerian law, any ruling reached under such circumstances is automatically void.

9. Introducing Claims With No Evidence

Experts describe as “alarming” the judge’s introduction of claims—such as plans to bomb foreign embassies—that:

Advertisement
  • Were not charged
  • Had no witnesses
  • Were not in any prosecution filings
  • Had no investigative backing

They say this violates judicial ethics and raises concerns about impartiality.

10. Conclusion: Experts Say the Judgment Cannot Survive Appeal

Based on the documented flaws—jurisdictional errors, constitutional violations, reliance on repealed laws, and introduction of extraneous claims—legal experts say the judgment is unlikely to withstand appellate review.
They also warn that the ruling raises broader concerns about judicial accountability and constitutional safeguards in politically sensitive cases.

WhatsApp

Stay ahead with VerseNews. Get the latest breaking news, insightful analysis, and trending stories. Your go-to source for timely updates and unbiased reporting.

Advertisement

WATCH: Nigeria Newspaper Headline Today

Apply For Latest Job Openings

Trending

IMG 7807 1786831477 IMG 7807 1786831477
Politics5 hours ago

Osun Accord Members Protest Unpaid of ₦50m Campaign Fund

A ₦50m mobilisation fund has sparked a dispute in Osun Accord, with supporters alleging non-payment while the PBAT movement coordinator...

Nancy Chidinma Nancy Chidinma
Entertainment5 hours ago

Don Jazzy Announces ₦5 Million Support for Woman Battling Recurring Keloids

Don Jazzy has announced ₦5 million support for Nancy Chidinma’s treatment after her appeal for help with recurring ear keloids...

IMG 20261107 WA0078 IMG 20261107 WA0078
Politics5 hours ago

‘You Will Not Regret It’ — Tinubu Assures Fubara Over Rivers Reconciliation

President Bola Tinubu has assured Governor Siminalayi Fubara that he will not regret embracing reconciliation, praising his role in efforts...

osim chel osim chel
Sports5 hours ago

Osimhen Missing as Chelle Names Super Eagles Squad for Tanzania Clashes — Full List

Victor Osimhen is absent from the Super Eagles squad as Eric Chelle selects 24 players for Nigeria’s 2027 AFCON qualifiers...

Umejiaku wins Golden ball award.jpg Umejiaku wins Golden ball award.jpg
Sports5 hours ago

Nigeria’s Umejiaku Wins Golden Ball After Flamingos’ World Cup Triumph, Award Full List

Oluebube Umejiaku has won the Golden Ball at the 2026 FIFA U-17 Women’s World Cup after helping Nigeria’s Flamingos secure...

oil 1 oil 1
News5 hours ago

Oil-Well Allegation: Winners, Deeper Life Reject Claim as RCCG Demands Evidence

Representatives of Winners’ Chapel and Deeper Life have rejected an oil-well claim involving their leaders, while an RCCG official says...

power min power min
News6 hours ago

BREAKING: Calls for Power Minister’s Resignation Intensify as Nigerians Remain in Darkness

Persistent blackouts have triggered calls for Power Minister Joseph Tegbe’s resignation, as civil society groups demand accountability and the minister...

D404872C C2BE 44FE 9FC0 83CCA0BFB022 1794089056 D404872C C2BE 44FE 9FC0 83CCA0BFB022 1794089056
Sports7 hours ago

World Champions! Nigeria’s Flamingos Make History as First African Team to Win FIFA U-17 Women’s World Cup (Video)

Nigeria’s Flamingos defeated Japan 2–1 to win their first FIFA U-17 Women’s World Cup, becoming the first African team to...

tinubuuuuuu tinubuuuuuu
Politics14 hours ago

2027: ‘Your Future Depends on this Election, Collect Your PVCs, Tinubu Tells Nigerian Youths

Tinubu urges youths to collect PVCs ahead of the 2027 elections, saying their future depends on the outcome and their...

Peter Obi VerseNews001 Peter Obi VerseNews001
Politics15 hours ago

Obi Challenges Tinubu to Account for ₦15.8tn Subsidy Savings, $100bn Borrowing

Obi challenges Tinubu to account for ₦15.8tn in reported subsidy savings and over $100bn in borrowing, questioning their impact on...

Advertisement